How to Manage Scope 3 Category 11 Emissions for Sustainability Reporting

What Are Scope 3 Emissions?

Scope 3 emissions are a critical component of an organization's overall greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions profile. Defined as indirect emissions that occur in a company’s value chain, Scope 3 emissions encompass all emissions not included in Scope 1 and Scope 2 categories. These emissions arise from both upstream and downstream activities related to the organization’s operations but are generated by sources that the company does not own or control directly.

Scope 3 Category 11 Emissions: Use of Sold Products

Scope 3 Category 11 specifically refers to the use of sold products, which encompasses all GHG emissions generated during the use phase of products sold by a company. This category is particularly relevant for products that consume energy throughout their lifecycle, such as automobiles, appliances, electronics, and industrial equipment.

In the context of Scope 3 emissions, particularly Category 11, it is essential to differentiate between Direct Use-Phase Emissions and Indirect Use-Phase Emissions. Both types of emissions are crucial for a comprehensive understanding of the environmental impact of products sold by companies. Here’s a detailed breakdown of each category:

Direct Use-Phase Emissions: 

Direct Use-Phase Emissions refer to the greenhouse gas emissions that occur as a direct result of the consumption of fuels or energy by products sold. These emissions are generated when consumers use the product in its intended manner, and they typically arise from the combustion of fossil fuels or other energy sources. These include emissions resulting from the direct consumption of fuels or energy by products sold (e.g., fuel used by cars)

Indirect Use-Phase Emissions: 

Indirect Use-Phase Emissions, on the other hand, represent the emissions associated with electricity or other energy sources consumed during the operation of a product but not directly tied to its combustion. These emissions occur upstream in the energy supply chain and are influenced by how electricity is generated and supplied to end-users. 

These encompass emissions associated with electricity or other energy sources consumed during the operation of a product (e.g., electricity used to power home appliances). 

Understanding both Direct and Indirect Use-Phase Emissions within Scope 3 Category 11 is essential for organizations aiming to reduce their overall carbon footprint. By addressing these two types of emissions comprehensively—through product design improvements, consumer education on efficient usage practices, and collaboration with energy providers—companies can significantly mitigate their environmental impact while enhancing their sustainability credentials.

Key Industries Affected by Scope 3 Category 11 Emissions

Scope 3 Category 11 emissions, which pertain to the use of sold products, represent a significant portion of greenhouse gas emissions for many industries. This category encompasses emissions generated during the operational phase of products sold by companies, impacting various sectors differently. 

Here, we will explore three key industries affected by these emissions: the automotive industry, the appliances industry, and the construction industry. Each section will provide illustrative examples to clarify how these emissions manifest and their broader implications. 

Automotive Industry: 

The automotive industry is one of the most prominent sectors impacted by Scope 3 Category 11 emissions. These emissions primarily arise from the fuel consumption of vehicles after they have been sold to consumers.

Gasoline-Powered Vehicles: 

When consumers operate gasoline-powered vehicles, they directly contribute to greenhouse gas emissions through fuel combustion. For instance, the average passenger vehicle emits about 130 grams of CO2 per km. If a typical driver covers about 12,000 km in a year, this results in approximately 1.6 metric tons of CO2 emitted annually from just one vehicle. Given that there are millions of gasoline vehicles on the road globally, the cumulative impact of these emissions is substantial.

The significance of these emissions becomes even clearer when considering that the International Energy Agency estimates that private cars and vans generate about 10% of energy-related carbon emissions globally. This highlights the automotive sector's pivotal role in addressing climate change and reducing GHG emissions. 

Electric Vehicles (EVs)

While electric vehicles do not emit greenhouse gases during operation, their indirect use-phase emissions can be significant depending on how the electricity used for charging is generated. 

If an EV consumes around 3,000 kWh over its lifetime and is charged using electricity from coal-fired power plants—which emit about 0.9 kg CO2 per kWh—this could lead to approximately 2.7 metric tons of CO2 emitted over its lifespan. This example underscores the importance of transitioning to renewable energy sources for charging EVs to minimize their overall environmental impact. 

As automakers push for more widespread adoption of EVs, they must also advocate for cleaner energy production methods to ensure that the shift to electric mobility contributes positively to reducing overall GHG emissions. 

Fleet Operations

Companies operating fleets of vehicles represent another significant source of Scope 3 Category 11 emissions. These fleets often include delivery trucks, service vehicles, and other commercial transportation options that consume large amounts of fuel.

A logistics company with a fleet of delivery trucks may find that its operations result in substantial GHG emissions due to fuel consumption during deliveries. For instance, if a delivery truck averages 10 miles per litre and travels 50,000 km annually, it would consume about 5,000 litres of diesel, leading to approximately 65 metric tons of CO2 emitted each year from that single vehicle alone. When considering an entire fleet, these figures can escalate quickly, emphasizing the need for fleet operators to seek lower-emission vehicles and more efficient logistics practices.

Scope 3 Category 11 emissions represent a critical challenge for the automotive industry as it seeks to align with global climate goals and consumer expectations for sustainability. By understanding the nature and impact of these emissions—particularly through gasoline-powered vehicles, electric vehicles, and fleet operations—automakers can develop targeted strategies to mitigate their environmental impact.

Appliances Industry: 

The appliances industry is a significant contributor to Scope 3 Category 11 emissions, which focus on the use of sold products. This category encompasses the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions generated during the operational phase of household appliances after they have been sold to consumers. Understanding these emissions is critical for manufacturers aiming to reduce their environmental impact and improve sustainability. 

Refrigerators

Refrigerators are ubiquitous in households and are used continuously, making them a major source of Scope 3 Category 11 emissions.

• Energy Consumption: A typical refrigerator consumes between 400 to 800 kWh per year, depending on its efficiency rating. This energy consumption translates directly into GHG emissions based on the source of electricity used. If powered by fossil fuels, this could result in approximately 1 metric ton of CO2 emitted over ten years of operation.
• Impact on GHG Emissions: Given that millions of refrigerators are in use worldwide, their collective impact on GHG emissions can be significant. The long lifespan of refrigerators means that even small efficiencies can lead to substantial reductions in total emissions over time.

This illustrates the importance of designing energy-efficient models and promoting consumer awareness about energy consumption.

As consumers become increasingly aware of their environmental footprint, addressing Scope 3 emissions will not only help companies comply with regulations but also position them favorably in an eco-conscious market where sustainability is paramount. By focusing on innovative product design, consumer education, and collaboration across supply chains, manufacturers can make significant strides toward reducing their overall environmental impact while meeting consumer demands for more sustainable solutions.

Addressing Scope 3 Category 11 Emissions in these sectors: 

In India, addressing Scope 3 Category 11 emissions, which pertain to the use of sold products, is crucial for achieving sustainability goals across various sectors, particularly in the automotive and appliances industries. As India aims for net-zero emissions by 2070, it is essential for businesses to implement effective strategies to manage these emissions, which significantly contribute to the overall carbon footprint.

Automotive Industry Initiatives:

The Indian automotive industry has been proactive in addressing Scope 3 emissions through several initiatives:

• Transition to Electric Vehicles (EVs): Major manufacturers like Tata Motors are leading the charge in developing electric and hybrid vehicles. The government’s Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of Electric Vehicles (FAME II) scheme supports this transition by providing subsidies for EV purchases, thereby encouraging consumers to opt for cleaner alternatives. This shift not only reduces direct emissions from vehicles but also addresses indirect emissions associated with fossil fuel use.
• Sustainable Fuel Options: The introduction of vehicles powered by alternative fuels such as CNG, LNG, and biofuels is another strategy being employed. Companies like Maruti Suzuki are developing biogas-powered vehicles, which help lower emissions during the use phase. The promotion of flex-fuel vehicles that can run on ethanol blends also plays a vital role in reducing reliance on conventional fuels.
• Compliance with Emission Norms: The adoption of Bharat Stage VI (BS VI) emission norms reflects the industry's commitment to reducing emissions. These stringent regulations compel manufacturers to innovate and produce cleaner vehicles, thereby lowering both direct and indirect emissions associated with vehicle operation.

Appliances Industry Strategies:

In the appliances sector, addressing Scope 3 emissions involves enhancing energy efficiency and promoting sustainable practices:

• Energy-Efficient Appliances: Manufacturers are increasingly focusing on producing energy-efficient appliances that consume less electricity during use. The Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) in India promotes star ratings for appliances based on their energy consumption, encouraging consumers to choose products that minimize indirect emissions.
• Consumer Awareness Campaigns: Educating consumers about the benefits of using energy-efficient appliances can lead to a significant reduction in overall energy consumption. Campaigns highlighting optimal usage practices can further enhance this effect, encouraging users to adopt habits that reduce electricity usage.
• Circular Economy Practices: Implementing recycling programs for end-of-life appliances helps minimize waste and promotes resource efficiency. This approach aligns with India's broader sustainability goals and reduces the environmental impact associated with appliance disposal.

Collaborative Efforts Across Sectors

Collaboration among stakeholders is essential for effectively managing Scope 3 Category 11 emissions:

• Engaging Stakeholders: Companies should engage with suppliers and customers to foster sustainable practices throughout the supply chain. Collaborations can lead to innovative solutions that reduce emissions associated with product use.
• Government Support: The Indian government plays a pivotal role by providing incentives and creating regulations that encourage sustainable practices across industries. Initiatives like the National Electric Mobility Mission Plan (NEMMP) aim to strengthen infrastructure for EV adoption and support manufacturers in transitioning toward greener technologies.
• Data Collection and Reporting: Utilizing platforms like StepChange's ESG Accelerator can help organizations track their Scope 3 emissions more effectively. By collecting accurate data and analyzing it, companies can identify key areas for improvement and set science-based targets aligned with national sustainability goals.

StepChange’s ESG Accelerator Can Help Measure Scope 3 Category 11 Emissions

StepChange's ESG Accelerator is a comprehensive software platform designed to empower organizations to effectively measure, analyze, report, and improve their Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) metrics. One of the critical areas the ESG Accelerator addresses is the measurement of Scope 3 Category 11 emissions, which pertain to the use of sold products. This section outlines how the ESG Accelerator facilitates accurate tracking and management of these emissions, ultimately supporting organizations in their sustainability goals.

Streamlined Data Collection

One of the primary challenges in measuring Scope 3 emissions is the complexity and variability of data sources across the supply chain. StepChange’s ESG Accelerator simplifies this process through:

• Automated Data Ingestion: The platform integrates seamlessly with various enterprise systems, allowing organizations to automatically collect and aggregate emissions data from multiple sources. This reduces manual data entry, minimizes errors, and ensures a more accurate representation of emissions related to product use.
• Standardized Data Workflows: With over 350 integrations available, organizations can standardize their data collection workflows across different departments and facilities, and their entire value chain. This unification of data helps ensure that all relevant emissions are captured comprehensively.

Enhanced Data Quality and Integrity

Accurate emissions reporting relies on high-quality data. StepChange’s ESG Accelerator addresses this need through:

• Data Quality Checks: The platform includes data validation features like anomaly detection that identify and flag inconsistencies or anomalies in the collected data. By proactively addressing data integrity issues, organizations can maintain reliable information essential for credible ESG reporting.
• Audit Trail and Version Control: StepChange's ESG Accelerator tracks changes made to data over time, ensuring transparency and accountability in reporting processes. This feature is particularly important for complex Scope 3 emissions calculations that involve multiple stakeholders.

Comprehensive Reporting Capabilities

Once emissions data is collected, organizations require robust reporting capabilities to disclose their Scope 3 Category 11 emissions accurately. The ESG Accelerator supports this through:

• Automated Reporting Features: The platform automates the generation of standardized reports that comply with various international and regional ESG reporting standards (such as BRSR, GRI, TCFD, and others). This not only saves time but also ensures that reports are audit-ready and meet regulatory requirements.
• Real-Time Dashboards: With real-time analytics capabilities, organizations can continuously monitor their emissions performance. This allows for timely adjustments in strategies to improve sustainability outcomes based on actual usage patterns of sold products.

Benchmarking and Target Setting

To effectively manage Scope 3 emissions, organizations need to set clear targets based on industry benchmarks. The ESG Accelerator assists with:

• Benchmarking Tools: Organizations can compare their emissions data against industry standards or peers, helping them understand their performance relative to others in their sector. This comparative analysis is vital for identifying areas for improvement.
• Target Setting: The platform provides guidance for establishing realistic and science-based targets for reducing overall emissions over time. By leveraging insights from benchmarking, organizations can create actionable plans to achieve their sustainability goals.

Science-Based Insights

StepChange's ESG Accelerator is built on a foundation of credible science and international standards. It enables organizations to:

• Set Science-Based Targets: Organizations can define targets aligned with global climate goals and track progress against these benchmarks. This approach ensures that emission reduction efforts are not only ambitious but also achievable.
• Identify Reduction Opportunities: By analyzing emission factors associated with product use, companies can pinpoint specific areas where they can implement changes to reduce overall Scope 3 emissions effectively.

StepChange's ESG Accelerator offers a powerful solution for measuring Scope 3 Category 11 emissions through streamlined data collection, enhanced data quality assurance, comprehensive reporting capabilities, benchmarking tools, and science-based insights. By leveraging these features, organizations can significantly improve their ability to measure, analyze, and report on their Scope 3 emissions.

This comprehensive approach not only aids compliance with regulatory requirements but also drives more sustainable practices throughout value chains. As businesses increasingly recognize the importance of addressing their environmental impact, StepChange’s ESG Accelerator positions them to lead in sustainability efforts while enhancing operational efficiency and transparency in their ESG initiatives.

Addressing Scope 3 Category 11 emissions is a critical imperative for businesses across various sectors, including automotive, appliances, and construction. As these emissions often represent a substantial portion of a company’s overall carbon footprint, understanding and managing them is essential for achieving sustainability goals and complying with increasing regulatory pressures.

Through innovative product design, enhanced energy efficiency, and collaborative efforts among stakeholders, organizations can significantly reduce their Scope 3 emissions. The integration of data-driven strategies and the adoption of technologies like StepChange's ESG Accelerator facilitates accurate measurement and reporting, empowering companies to set science-based targets aligned with global climate objectives.

In the Indian context, where rapid industrial growth intersects with the urgent need for environmental stewardship, addressing Scope 3 emissions is not just beneficial but necessary. By embracing sustainable practices and engaging consumers in their sustainability journeys, businesses can contribute to India's commitment to achieving net-zero emissions by 2070.

Ultimately, the proactive management of Scope 3 Category 11 emissions positions companies as leaders in sustainability, enhancing their reputation and competitiveness in an increasingly eco-conscious market. As organizations take meaningful steps toward reducing their environmental impact, they play a vital role in fostering a more sustainable future for all.

‍